EclectEcon

Economics and the mid-life crisis have much in common: Both dwell on foregone opportunities

C'est la vie; c'est la guerre; c'est la pomme de terre                                     A View from/of the Econochasm by John Palmer

Richard Posner deserves the next Nobel Prize in Economics
Please consider using these links if you are ordering from Amazon: Amazon.com, Amazon.ca, Amazon.uk

<< main
Minimum Wages and Capital-Labour Substitution
With all the on-going discussion in the blogosphere concerning the effects of minimum wage legislation (e.g. see this at Cafe Hayek, this at Market Power, and this by Greg Mankiw; and see this earlier piece by Craig Newmark), I'd like to add these observations.

Some years ago, a professor in socionomology argued that raising minimum wages wouldn't cause job losses in the fast food industry because you'd still need workers (graduates from his department, probably) to flip burgers.

There are two problems with this so-called analysis.
  1. It assumes a fixed-coefficents production function [you need a fixed proportion of labour and capital, no matter how much you produce] in the fast-food industry. But as one who has happily worked and consumed in the fast-food industry for nearly half a century, I can assure you that production techniques are changing all the time. And much of the technological change that is implemented seems to allow the substitution of capital for labour.
  2. The second problem is both larger and more subtle. As minimum wages increase in the fast-food industry, prices rise too. And as the prices of fast food increase, people start buying more microwavable food in grocery stores, storing it at home in freezers, and preparing it themselves. The substitution of capital for labour takes place in the factories that produce the food, in the grocery stores, and people's homes, not in the fast-food restaurants themselves, but it is every bit as important a phenomenon.
For a good but lengthy summary of the economics of minimum wages, see this.
<< main






To leave a comment, please post as "guest"
Fred (mail):
In addition to capital - labour substitution there is labour - labour substitution. Gone into the mists of history and legend is the full service gas station and attendants. Self serve is the job formerly known as attendant and it is your job at the true minimum wage: Zero.

Burger flippers can be replaced by people who go back to cooking at home, flipping their own burgers. I'll have to see if I can get a publisher to bite on The Self Serve Cookbook.
1.17.2007 12:49pm
KipEsquire (mail) (www):
As minimum wages increase in the fast-food industry, prices rise too. And as the prices of fast food increase, people start buying more microwavable food in grocery stores, storing it at home in freezers, and preparing it themselves."
And even if they don't, consumers of fast food are far more likely to be lower-income. So if your putative policy goal is to "help the poor," then raising the minimum wage that the working poor earn only transfers income from poor consumers to poor workers.

Not very helpful, is it?
1.17.2007 1:41pm
© 2005